Skip to main content

Book Review: Bankers in the Ivory Tower

Book review of Charlie Eaton’s Bankers in the Ivory Tower: The Troubling Rise of Financiers in US Higher Education (2022)

Published onMay 15, 2024
Book Review: Bankers in the Ivory Tower
history

You're viewing an older Release (#1) of this Pub.

  • This Release (#1) was created on May 15, 2024 at 6:15 PM ()
  • The latest Release (#2) was created on May 15, 2024 at 6:20 PM ().

Bankers in the Ivory Tower: The Troubling Rise of Financiers in US Higher Education, by Charlie Eaton (2022). Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Charlie Eaton’s Bankers in the Ivory Tower: The Troubling Rise of Financiers in US Higher Education is a necessary if not timely analysis for understanding the higher-education crisis in the contemporary United States. Although some researchers have begun to study this crisis by examining rising student debt, few have linked the debt crisis to the role of financiers in higher education and their investments in elite private universities. Eaton sheds light on how financiers have influenced and restructured the U.S. higher-education system by examining the relationship between student debt and the financial endowments of elite private universities.

While primary data on financiers’ involvement may be difficult to access over the course of seven years (12), Eaton’s methodology of limited primary interviews, secondary studies, and publicly available documents nonetheless reveal what he describes as the “social circuitry of finance” (3) in higher education. To this end, the introductory chapter lays out the book’s thesis of how financiers have benefitted from the student debt crisis and the “endowment cultures” of elite private universities. Eaton shows how financiers are involved in building social ties and networks through their investments on behalf of university endowments. Since such investments make financiers eligible for tax exemptions worth billions of dollars, there are not enough leftover funds to support public higher education. This “squeezing” of funds in public higher education (4) has also contributed to the rise of subsidies for for-profit colleges, which are often backed by the same financiers. Eaton outlines how this financier-driven strategy has created a hierarchical system (in three layers) in which the elite private universities occupy the top position, public universities the middle, and for-profit colleges the bottom of the overall U.S. higher-education system.

The second chapter, “Our New Financial Oligarchy,” explains how financiers have established their influence in higher education. In the past, financiers relied on banking cartels to assert their monopoly on markets. Eaton describes how the new financial oligarchs do not have to rely on such organizations, but instead can rely on their social connections to increase their collective status and wealth. For instance, Eaton points out that in 2002, a group of Yale and Harvard alumni used insider knowledge on planned steel tariffs to bolster their income and influence on state policy vis-à-vis steel tariffs. While such favors boost these insiders’ wealth and power, their monetary gains also resulted in generous donations to the endowments of said institutions.

The third chapter, “Bankers to the Rescue,” observes how the new financial oligarchs’ interest in higher education has also deepened the student-debt crisis. Since tax exemptions for financial endowments have depleted much of the funding allocated for public higher education, the U.S. federal government has been unable to meet concurrent demands for better education. However, instead of taxing the rich, politicians and policy makers have allowed said bankers to become benefactors of their elite alma maters. In this capacity, these bankers have expanded federal student loan programs and increased students’ collective dependence on loans.

In the fourth, fifth, and sixth chapters, Eaton explains how the infusion of capital into elite private institutions has catapulted them to the top rung of the higher-education ladder, while pushing public universities to the middle, and for-profit institutions to the bottom. The fourth chapter, “The Top,” describes how elite private institutions have become hedge funds of sorts by cementing social ties with financiers, while strengthening their prestige, wealth, and power.  Evidently, endowments have enabled their managers to be entrusted with access to information, what Eaton describes as the “high-finance advantage” (56), which has led to “philanthropic homophily” (56), whereby financiers inevitably promote the endowment wealth of their own alma maters.

In the fifth and sixth chapters, entitled “The Bottom” and “The Middle,” Eaton demonstrates how financiers have expanded their reach into the middle and the bottom layers of higher education. In “The Bottom,” Eaton shows how the expansion of federal loan programs and the rise of the “shareholder value movement among investors and corporate managers” (77) have encouraged the “Wall Street takeover” (77) of for-profit colleges. Although takeovers have long been common among private-equity managers wishing to control shares in targeted businesses, such actions have also had far-reaching implications in higher education. For instance, for-profit educational institutions are often driven toward increasing enrollments and tuition fees. They have also been left largely un-regulated and -evaluated for quality. Eaton explains this dynamic through the case study of the now-defunct New England Institute of Art (NEIA), a for-profit institution managed by Educational Management Corporation (EDMC). Soon after the takeover of EDMC by financier Jonathan Nelson, NEIA attracted the scrutiny of the U.S. Department of Justice by committing fraud, illegally paying its recruiters to “[misrepresent] placement rates” (85) and “financial aid” packages (85).

In “The Middle,” Eaton looks at the middle strata of the public higher-education institutions in the United States. While financiers have systematically amplified the wealth of those institutions at the top, they have simultaneously increased their shareholder wealth in poor-quality for-profit institutions, which has also resulted in cuts to the funding of public universities. Even as financiers have benefited from subsidies and tax cuts and have received more resources through their connections with elite institutions, legislatures have systematically underfunded the public higher-education institutions in their states. These factors, along with an increase in graduation rates at secondary schools, have led to an increased dependency on external financing, as opposed to state funding. An emphasis on student loans and direct bond-market borrowing has further decreased the amount of funding for public higher education. In this sense, financiers have leveraged their personal and impersonal connections to secure power and prestige, leaving others (outside these circles) to be dependent on expensive and less-advantageous educational experiences.

Although the nexus between financiers and universities would be near impossible to sever, Eaton explains how this relationship can be utilized towards generating gains for higher education. In the final chapter, “Reimagining (Higher Education) Finance from Below,” Eaton draws from his personal experience and explains how the University of California-Berkeley organized a large-scale, student-run movement to tax millionaires. Since many working-class students from diverse backgrounds have incurred debt, the movement effectively mobilized different coalitions and lobbied legislators to support their demand for taxation. In other words, their shared identity as debtors unified the protestors and legislators to initiate reforms that could allocate additional funds to public higher education.

According to Eaton, such strategies of “bargaining with the bankers” can engender reforms that are far more sustainable than the “financial big bang” strategy of cancelling student debt (123). Although this initiative to mobilize students is illuminating, the strategy depends heavily on the good faith of legislators and policymakers who are empathetic to the experience of student debt. However, it is also true that the “big bang” strategy to cancel student debt has led to more resistance from state governments as well as from the financiers themselves. It is in this context that Eaton’s book gestures toward a new form of political mobilization, one involving the public stakeholders in the management of higher education. In sum, Eaton’s short but well-argued book may be of interest to pedagogues, sociologists, and political scientists. Although the book is not supported by significant primary evidence, it does make a valid case toward understanding the extensive reach of financiers in higher education in the contemporary United States.

Author Biography:

Deepti Sreeram is a third-year doctoral student of sociology and anthropology at Ashoka University, India. Her research examines the question of quality in higher education in Kerala.

Comments
28
?
Suman Sharma:

Escaping Loneliness with Professional Companions: Loneliness can be a burden, but Delhi Escort Agency offer a safe and discreet escape. Professionally trained independent escorts offer companionship and intimacy, catering to your individual needs.

?
ycoav qvj5f:

Hamilton Lindley Composing with style and getting great compliments on the article is very hard, to be honest.But you've done it so serenely and with so cool feeling and you've nailed the activity. This article is had with style and I am giving great compliment. Best!

?
ycoav qvj5f:

Hamilton Philip Lindley To a great degree lovely and captivating post. I was hunting down this kind of information and acknowledged examining this one. Keep posting. Thankful for sharing.

?
mahmoud shaheen:

We repair small household appliances such as blenders,

صيانة مولينكس food processors, microwaves, and heaters, and we work in the Arab Republic of Egypt in Cairo and Giza.

We repair small household appliances such as blenders,

صيانة مولينكس food processors, microwaves, and heaters, and we work in the Arab Republic of Egypt in Cairo and Giza.

We repair small household appliances such as blenders,

صيانة مولينكس food processors, microwaves, and heaters, and we work in the Arab Republic of Egypt in Cairo and Giza.

?
mahmoud shaheen:

We repair small household appliances such as blenders,

صيانة مولينكس food processors, microwaves, and heaters, and we work in the Arab Republic of Egypt in Cairo and Giza.

We repair small household appliances such as blenders,

صيانة مولينكس food processors, microwaves, and heaters, and we work in the Arab Republic of Egypt in Cairo and Giza.

We repair small household appliances such as blenders,

صيانة مولينكس food processors, microwaves, and heaters, and we work in the Arab Republic of Egypt in Cairo and Giza.

?
mahmoud shaheen:

We repair small household appliances such as blenders,

صيانة مولينكس food processors, microwaves, and heaters, and we work in the Arab Republic of Egypt in Cairo and Giza.

We repair small household appliances such as blenders,

<a href="https://moulinex.maintenance-centers.com/">صيانة مولينكس</a> food processors, microwaves, and heaters, and we work in the Arab Republic of Egypt in Cairo and Giza.

We repair small household appliances such as blenders,

[url=https://moulinex.maintenance-centers.com]صيانة مولينكس[/url] food processors, microwaves, and heaters, and we work in the Arab Republic of Egypt in Cairo and Giza.

?
ycoav qvj5f:

롤 배팅 사이트 The accuracy of a sports odds API is crucial for both bettors and sportsbooks. It ensures that everyone has access to the same information, reducing the risk of disputes.

?
ycoav qvj5f:

Ruby stone I at last discovered grand post here.I will get back here. I just added your blog to my bookmark districts. thanks.Quality presents is the major on welcome the guests to visit the site page, that is the thing that this site page is giving.

?
ycoav qvj5f:

메이저 안전놀이터 The Eat and Run Police are a creative way to tackle a frustrating problem. Hopefully, this will make people think twice before skipping out on the bill.

?
ycoav qvj5f:

먹튀스팟 보증업체 The Sports Toto site is my top pick for sports betting. The site is secure, and the betting options are fantastic.

?
ycoav qvj5f:

LED module bulk order I’ve started using LED grow lights for my indoor plants, and the results have been fantastic. They provide the perfect spectrum of light, and my plants are thriving like never before.

?
ycoav qvj5f:

Squirrel Control Services Keep your home safe from squirrel damage with Toronto's top Squirrel Control Services. They offer reliable, humane solutions.

?
ycoav qvj5f:

해운대오션룸, 부산오션룸 주대 가격 안내. 해운대오션룸

?
ycoav qvj5f:

Drinks Chocolate fondue is always fun to make. Dipping fruits, marshmallows, and even pretzels into melted chocolate is a treat for both kids and adults.

?
ycoav qvj5f:

Topeka (city in Kansas) Attempting to express profound gratitude won't just be sufficient, for the fantasti c lucidity in your composed work. I will rapidly get your rss channel to stay taught of any updates.

?
ycoav qvj5f:

صيانة غسالات اتوماتيك Our Riyadh washing machines maintenance services are designed to handle all your appliance care needs.

?
ycoav qvj5f:

bruciatore a gas per forno pizza Bruciatore a Gas per Forno Pizza: Serious about pizza? A gas burner for your pizza oven ensures that perfect, crispy crust every time. Elevate your pizza-making game!

?
ycoav qvj5f:

daftar duniacash slot Duniacash has made digital transactions so much simpler for me. The app is intuitive, and the process is always smooth.

?
ycoav qvj5f:

slot gacor hari ini I’ve had the best time playing slot gacor hari ini today. The wins just keep coming, and the game is so much fun!

?
ycoav qvj5f:

origin data electronics Electronic components are the building blocks of all modern devices. From resistors to capacitors, each component plays a vital role in the function of circuits.

?
Peter Kyle:

"Bankers in the Ivory Tower" offers a critical examination of the financial industry's influence on higher education. The book delves into how banks and financial elites shape university policies and priorities, often at the expense of academic integrity. This insightful read is essential for anyone interested in the intersection of finance and academia. It raises important questions about the future of higher education and its alignment with public good. https://therahealthwellness.com/

?
Ateeb khatri:

A fake diploma may help you in buy fake diploma the short term, but it won't provide the lasting benefits of real education. Building your skills and knowledge through accredited programs is a more sustainable and ethical approach to career advancement.

?
ycoav qvj5f:

fake transcript maker Using a fake transcript maker can be risky. While it might seem like a quick fix to meet some immediate needs, relying on fake transcripts can lead to severe consequences if discovered. It’s always better to work on improving genuine academic records or qualifications rather than resorting to deceitful methods.

Sapna [email protected]:

If you visit the house alone, you can meet Model Escorts in Greater Kailash. Many people are worried and afraid to use escort services or meet free Call girls. our Greater Kailash Escorts Service are aimed at high profile individuals and our attractive services bring this to this much more than we care about 100% satisfaction of our customers. We are always proud of free hostels and hotels in Greater Kailash that provide good service to their customers. Instead of paying high prices we offer good management and lovely Call Girls.

ayesha khan:

In simple word you can say that at Gwalior Escort Service you can find reliable and trusted girls without any problems. It’s the quality of our escort that an immediate action is to be produced in your thoughts for sex and without any moment spending method you appreciate a lot with our escort, even you really experience sad and having adverse thoughts but when you do sex-related therapy with our escort all adverse thing is to be eliminated and you really experience more satisfaction rather than other days. Gwalior Female Escort is most chosen and affordable escort support for each customer, which is the reason in present time the use of our escort support, is higher than other Call Girls Service in Gwalior

Alice Magnet:

I have read the Friday Night Funkin introduction to this book. It's quite interesting, I'll try to read it

?
Peter Kyle:

Bankers in the Ivory Tower" offers a thought-provoking exploration of the intersection between academia and finance. Through meticulous research and insightful analysis, the book sheds light on the influence of academic economists on financial policy and practice. It challenges conventional wisdom and prompts readers to reconsider the role of intellectual elites in shaping economic ideologies and decisions. https://www.chambers.com.au/forum/view_post.php?frm=1&pstid=55045

?
Jack Ali:

From a financial perspective, investing in quality insulation can significantly increase the value of a property. Homebuyers today are increasingly concerned about energy efficiency and environmental sustainability, and a well-insulated home is often perceived as more desirable and valuable. https://www.ottawainsulations.ca/

?
Nadia moore:

The 2024 SEA/SAW Spring Meeting focused on the intersection of work and the data economy, exploring how digital data's production, distribution, and consumption are reshaping economic activities and labor practices.

In a similar vein of exploring new terrains, the Slope game invites players to navigate a digital landscape where speed and precision are key. It's a game that mirrors the agility needed in today's data-driven world, offering endless slopes of challenges and excitement.