Skip to main content

Book Review: Beyond the Algorithm

A review of the 2021 book edited by Deepa Das Acevedo and published by Cambridge University Press.

Published onOct 22, 2021
Book Review: Beyond the Algorithm
·

Beyond the Algorithm: Qualitative Insights for Gig Work Regulation, edited by Deepa Das Acevedo (2021). New York: Cambridge University Press.

This edited volume provides a law- and policy-oriented overview of the challenges that the gig economy has created for workers and regulators. Unlike much of the related scholarship in the fields of law and policy studies, however, Beyond the Algorithm approaches the gig economy from the vantage point of qualitative research. Edited by legal anthropologist Deepa Das Acevedo, the volume is comprised of U.S.-based case studies written by a diverse cadre of academics and experts. It pursues two goals: to disseminate information about the gig economy that may be of interest for legal scholars and policymakers, and to showcase the necessity of qualitative empirical data for the development of policies and laws. Both endeavors are timely and important, especially since—as Das Acevedo points out in her introduction—the gig economy is generally secretive and little understood, especially by its users. What is known too often rests, on the one hand, on journalistic accounts, and on the other, on purely quantitative data. In the absence of rigorous, long-term engagement with workers’ experiences and voices, several of the volume’s contributors suggest, exploitative work practices are poorly understood and therefore poorly regulated.

In Chapter 1, Das Acevedo outlines the foundational elements of existing regulation of the gig economy in the United States, ranging from federal case law to state-level adjudication, and from federal legislative and administrative developments to state and local ordinances. Das Acevedo argues that, while the responses of state actors to the challenges posed by the gig economy have been uneven, courts have become consistently involved in the effort to establish all-important legal classifications of gig workers. The issue of classification is further developed in Chapter 2, where V. B. Dubal explores the ambiguities navigated by gig workers themselves. Drawing on qualitative empirical data, Dubal surmises that while many rideshare drivers would appreciate the benefits provided by stable employment, they also enjoy the freedom and flexibility that their role as independent contractors putatively grants them. What gig workers need, Dubal suggests, is access to the protections usually afforded to employees, even as they retain some of the flexibility found in current arrangements.

In investigating workers’ experiences with the website care.com, Chapter 3 provides nuanced insight into the experiences of nannies, housecleaners, and eldercare workers who use this online platform to compete for gigs. Its authors, Alexandra Mateescu and Julia Ticona, argue that contrary to the common belief about platform labor rendering workers invisible, care.com in fact makes workers visible in a way that can become uncomfortable. In asking workers to post their profiles, the platform seeks to establish clients’ trust in the workers. However, gig workers experience this visibility as a form of control that many are unable to manage; given the competition on the app, posting a good selfie and drafting a brief biography are rarely enough to hold the attention of potential clients. Other services offered by care.com, such as badges that vouch for individual gig workers’ records, can put an additional financial strain on workers without guaranteeing any return on this investment. Furthermore, while some younger, educated, and tech-savvy workers are able to get ahead, others are frustrated by biased algorithms that penalize them for, among other things, the texture of their hair or their proficiency in English as a second language. Mateescu and Ticona’s conclusion is that, notwithstanding their claims of neutrality, care platforms are riddled with many of the same inequalities and contradictions that characterize traditional arrangements for domestic workers.

In Chapter 4, Shy-Yi Oei and Diane M. Ring argue for the importance of qualitative empirical research in learning how gig workers approach tax questions. In order to do so, the authors suggest, policymakers should pay attention to the very spaces that gig workers use to exchange information: online forums and face-to-face communities. Chapter 5, in turn, analyzes the implications of gig work for its participants’ future career trajectories. By exploring gig workers’ own experiences, Alexandra J. Ravenelle finds that the side hustles many take on frequently become impediments in their pursuit of gainful employment. Trapped in gig work characterized by low earnings and long working hours, rideshare drivers end up extending their precarity indefinitely. “Caveat venditor: seller beware” (p. 120) is Ravenelle’s admonition to those who peddle their labor on online platforms.

Chapter 6, by Julia Tommassetti, engages in a close examination of the Uber app and its byzantine end-user license agreement (EULA). Tommassetti’s conclusion is that Uber uses both the EULA and the app itself to continually recalibrate agreements with its drivers and modifying its obligations to them—all, of course, to the company’s advantage. In Chapter 7, Zack Accuardi considers the adverse impact of companies such as Uber and Lyft on both transit systems and the environment, concluding that it would be beneficial to devolve regulatory responsibilities to local governments.

In Chapter 8, Sam Harnett describes how “swooning” tech journalists came to hail gig platforms as “disruptive, liberating, and futuristic” (p. 170); this one-sided judgment ended up influencing the decisions of politicians, legislators, and judges, thus abetting labor practices that should have been subjected to much closer scrutiny. In Chapter 9, Rebecca Smith and Maya Pinto explore the myriad ways in which gig companies manage to shape the regulations affecting them, thus preempting challenges to their employment practices. Finally, in Chapter 10, Harry Campbell draws on his own experience as a rideshare driver and his conversations with fellow Uber and Lyft workers to establish that, strapped for time, drivers are rarely able to lobby for their interests, even when the circumstances of their work are plainly exploitative. For Campbell, it is imperative that regulators elicit gig workers’ perspectives and listen to their experiences in crafting much-needed legislation.

In addressing an audience of law and policy studies scholars, Beyond the Algorithm provides a valuable supplement to what is known about the plights facing gig workers; however, the edited volume offers less insight to ethnographers themselves, even as it makes a forceful case for the importance of qualitative research. While not intended for an anthropological audience, Beyond the Algorithm can nonetheless be a useful resource for ethnographers who want to understand the economic, regulatory, and ethical challenges facing today’s gig laborers and to play a part in the development of policies and laws that address them.

Author Bio

Emanuela Guano is Professor of Anthropology at Georgia State University. Her current research entails an ethnographic exploration of the role of aesthetics in the resistance to redevelopment in the postindustrial peripheries of Genoa, Italy. Her previous work has been featured in Cultural AnthropologyCity and SocietyGender, Place and Culture, and Ethnos; she is also the author of Creative Urbanity: An Italian Middle Class in the Shade of Revitalization (University of Pennsylvania Press, 2017).

Comments
9
?
Sneha Patel:

Our promise is the utmost discretion and the utmost quality - always. Relish in the earthly pleasures for an hour, an evening, a night or more. No matter the length of the encounter you choose you can be assured of complete and utter satisfaction. Our private Ghaziabad Call Girls will treat, titillate, seduce and do so with a finesse only possible when in the company of a true woman.

?
Yasmin Ansari:

Who will help you to give more pleasure and make your night so adorable. With sex and a beautiful Escorts Service near Lemon Tree Hotel companion, you make your life colorful. They are too gorgeous and high-class model escorts. They are fully horny and genuine escorts.

john babu:

You have to enjoy more time with Goa Escort Service Russian Escort partner while you are on a business trip; you want to provide presents and enjoy all the chances for her. If both of these activities are distracted and unwilling to do, so don't go into that Serious Partnership. Select a Girlfriend Experience who will still give you endless support and compassion

?
Shweta Roy:

We are devoted and serious about preserving your convenience personally and properly secured and our girls are properly certified according to our company recommendations. Get Instant Confirmation by Mahipalpur Call Girls Village near Radisson Blu Plaza Hotel and we offer to know that convenience is the key to our services with free hotel delivery so that our clients can appreciate their lifestyle quickly and certainly

Swarna Yadav:

Whenever you have got gotten a chance to seem at our different Angel displays and you have got chosen your preferred provocative Delhi Escort if it’s not an excessive amount of trouble, act and call our well disposed gathering group on and that they are going to be exceptionally glad to create the courses of action for you.

Ruby Rajput:

Here you will get the only selected companion in form of professional escort with high living standard, we never add any street hookers or road side prostitute profile on our website. Hiring female Goa Escorts from our agency will serve you with a plethora of benefits. Where you get transparent and premium escorts services in Goa for supreme adult entertainment. 


Lisa Dsouza:

Their erotic dance moves will sweep you off your feet that you will lose control. The moment you will gaze at them from head to toe, you will instantly fall head over heels in love with them, but don’t you worry? Our mature Escort in Goa will add charm to your life even your wife or girlfriend would not be able to do. 


?
james an:

One of the most appreciated aspects of Mod APKs is the removal of intrusive advertisements. Users can enjoy a seamless, ad-free experience while using their favorite apps, without interruptions that can often disrupt the flow of the user experience.

this content

have a peek at these guys

check my blog

?
Abbot 00:

When it comes to tablets for young children, the most important factor to consider is safety. A good option for kids is the Amazon Fire HD 8 Kids Edition, which comes with a kid-proof case and a two-year worry-free guarantee. This tablet is also equipped with parental controls, allowing you to set limits on what your child can access, as well as enabling you to monitor their online activity. https://workusingtablets.com/best-tablet-for-reading/